▰ Awesome stayguide
← All things to do Restaurants & Bistros · Old Arlington

Northstar Cafe, Lane Avenue

The Columbus-born cafe that made a black-bean veggie burger famous, doing all-day breakfast, big salads and proper coffee on Upper Arlington's best-connected corner.

Where
Old Arlington
Time needed
1 hr visit
Tickets
$14-$18 a main
Counter and communal tables at a bright modern cafe on West Lane Avenue Counter and communal tables at a bright modern cafe on West Lane Avenue

What to expect at Northstar Cafe, Lane Avenue

Northstar Cafe began in the Short North in the mid-2000s and grew into a small central Ohio group without ever turning into a chain in the dispiriting sense — the food is still cooked to order, the produce still leans local and organic, and the room still fills with a genuine cross-section of the city. The Lane Avenue branch is the Upper Arlington one, on the southern edge of the city where the road runs toward Ohio State, and it is the single most useful restaurant address for a visitor staying here. It serves all day without a break between lunch and dinner, it does breakfast until closing, it takes no reservations, and it costs about half what a sit-down dinner elsewhere on the same road will. If you eat one meal in Upper Arlington that is not a doughnut, this is the safest bet.

The format is order-at-the-counter, take a number, and food is brought to the table. The menu is short and repeats itself well: the Northstar burger, a black-bean, brown-rice and beetroot patty that converted a generation of Columbus carnivores; a rotating collection of large salads built on kale, grains and roasted vegetables; a breakfast burrito and a pile of scrambled eggs with sourdough toast; soups; a nut-and-fruit bowl; and cakes and cookies on the counter that are better than they need to be. Coffee is taken seriously — espresso, cortado, drip — and there are fresh juices and smoothies. The room is bright, wood-heavy and loud at peak, with communal tables, a window counter and outdoor seats in warm weather.

Plan around the fact that there are no reservations. Weekday mid-afternoon, roughly 14:00 to 16:30, you walk in and sit anywhere. Weekend brunch between 10:30 and 13:30 is the worst queue of the week and can run twenty to thirty minutes before you even order. Order at the counter, pay, and expect eight to fifteen minutes for the food. If you want a quiet table, ask for the far side of the room away from the door. What to skip: coming here hungry at noon on a Saturday with small children and no plan. What to do instead: come at 08:30 on a weekday, take a coffee and a breakfast burrito, and be out in forty minutes having spent under $15.

Getting there is simple. The cafe sits on West Lane Avenue at the Lane Avenue shopping block, about a mile south of Tremont Center and a mile and a half west of the Ohio State campus. From downtown Columbus take I-670 west to SR-315 north, exit Lane Avenue and drive west — five miles, twelve to eighteen minutes. Parking is free in the surface bays and the adjacent structure, with no validation, though the bays nearest the door fill from late morning. COTA runs the Lane Avenue corridor, which makes this the easiest Upper Arlington restaurant to reach without a car; check the current timetable for evening frequency. Rideshare is roughly $13-$20 from downtown and $8-$12 from campus. Cyclists can reach it from the Olentangy Trail in about ten minutes via Lane Avenue.

Costs are clear and posted. Mains sit around $14-$18: the Northstar burger and the big salads land in that band, breakfast plates run $11-$16, soup and half-salad combinations about $12-$14, and a breakfast burrito around $12-$14. Coffee is $3.50-$5.50, a fresh juice or smoothie $7-$9, cakes and cookies $4-$7, and beer or wine by the glass roughly $7-$12. Two people eating a main each with coffee will spend $40-$50 before tip; a solo breakfast with coffee is $15-$20. Counter service means tipping is optional in the strict sense, but the tablet will prompt you and 10-15% is normal here. There is no cover charge, no service charge and no separate children's admission — children eat from the same menu, and staff will happily split a plate.

When to go, hour by hour: 08:00-09:30 on a weekday is the best time in the building, calm and sunlit, with the pastry case full. 11:45-13:15 is the weekday lunch rush, still manageable. 17:30-19:30 brings the family dinner crowd. Weekends are a different animal — 10:30 to 14:00 is a sustained queue, and 12:00 is the peak. Ohio State home football Saturdays overwhelm the whole corridor from late morning. Month by month, the pavement tables make May to October the nicest, and January and February are the quietest months of the year, when a Tuesday lunch feels almost private. The kitchen does not close between services, which is genuinely useful if you have arrived off a flight at 15:30.

It suits almost everybody, which is the point of it. Vegetarians and vegans are properly catered for rather than tolerated, gluten-free choices are marked, families get high chairs and quick food, and solo diners can sit at the window without feeling odd. Access is step-free from the car park, tables are spaced enough for a wheelchair and the toilets are accessible. Teenagers like it. It suits a one-hour gap perfectly because the food arrives fast. Who should skip it: anyone wanting table service and a wine list — walk five minutes west to Hudson 29 for that — and anyone who dislikes noise, because at peak the room is genuinely loud and the communal tables mean sharing space with strangers.

What else to fold in: the Whole Foods and the rest of the Lane Avenue shops are a two-minute walk for groceries or a forgotten raincoat, and Hudson 29 is five minutes west on the same road for a later drink. Northam Park is under a mile north if you want to walk lunch off, and the Mallway and Old Arlington's 1920s streets are a six to eight minute drive northeast. The Ohio State campus, Ohio Stadium and the Wexner Center for the Arts are a mile and a half east, an easy pre-match or post-gallery pairing. The Olentangy Trail is ten minutes away at the river, and Griggs Reservoir Park about ten minutes west along Fifth Avenue for an after-dinner sunset over the water.

The honest caveats: the queue at weekend brunch is worse than visitors expect and there is nowhere comfortable to wait, so arrive before 10:30 or after 14:00. The menu is short and does not change dramatically, which is a virtue if you love it and a limitation if you are eating here twice in a week. Portions are generous but prices have crept up, and $18 for a salad still surprises people. It is not a quiet romantic dinner and never has been. And do not confuse it with a full-service restaurant: you order at the counter, carry your own drinks and clear roughly after yourself, which some visitors read as casual and others as thin service for the money.

Plan your visit Tickets$14-$18 a main Time needed1 hr visit WhereOld Arlington Opening hours Mon-Fri 8:00-21:00 Sat-Sun 9:00-21:00 Kitchen serves all day, no break Hotels near Northstar Cafe, Lane Avenue

Questions about Northstar Cafe, Lane Avenue

How much does it cost to eat at Northstar Cafe?

Mains sit at $14-$18, breakfast plates $11-$16, the breakfast burrito about $12-$14, and soup with half a salad $12-$14. Coffee is $3.50-$5.50, juices and smoothies $7-$9, cakes $4-$7 and beer or wine by the glass $7-$12. Two people with a main each and coffee spend $40-$50 before tip. Counter service means tipping is discretionary; 10-15% is what most locals leave on the card prompt.

Are there free or discounted times?

There is no discount programme, no happy hour and no free window — the pricing is the same at 08:00 and at 20:00. The cheapest way to eat here is breakfast: eggs and toast or a burrito with drip coffee comes in around $15 a head, roughly a third less than a dinner main with a drink. Portions are large enough that two people can genuinely share one main and a soup at lunch.

How long does a meal take?

About an hour door to door at a normal time. Ordering takes two to five minutes off-peak, food arrives in eight to fifteen, and most people are done in forty-five minutes. At weekend brunch between 10:30 and 14:00 add twenty to thirty minutes of queueing before you even reach the till. If you are squeezing it into a one-hour gap, come on a weekday and order at the counter rather than sitting down first.

What days is it closed?

It opens daily, typically Monday to Friday from 8:00 and weekends from 9:00, serving until around 21:00 with no afternoon break. Thanksgiving and Christmas Day are closed, and hours shorten on other major public holidays and sometimes on New Year's Day. Because the kitchen runs straight through, it is one of the few reliable options in Upper Arlington at 15:00, when most full-service restaurants here are between services.

Can I book a table?

No. Northstar does not take reservations at any of its cafes, including this one, at any hour or for any group size. Larger parties simply queue like everyone else and are seated when a suitable table clears, which at weekend brunch can mean half an hour. If you need a guaranteed table for a group in Upper Arlington, book Hudson 29 five minutes west on Lane Avenue instead.

What is the nearest stop or parking?

Parking is free at the Lane Avenue shops, in both surface bays and the adjacent structure, with no validation needed; the bays nearest the door fill from late morning. COTA serves the West Lane Avenue corridor, giving this the best bus access of any Upper Arlington restaurant, though evening frequency thins. Rideshare runs $13-$20 from downtown Columbus and $8-$12 from the Ohio State campus, a mile and a half east.

Where to stay

Hotels near Northstar Cafe, Lane Avenue

Live prices · free cancellation
Browse

Every hotel we cover in Old Arlington

24 with a full page

More things to do

All things to do

From the journal

All posts
Indoor hotel pool lit at night near a Columbus suburban hotel corridor Comparisons & rankings Hotels with pools near Upper Arlington, ranked

Upper Arlington packs three city pools and almost no hotel rooms into 9.8 square miles, so every swimmable stay sits a 5 to 20 minute drive out — here are seven clusters ranked, at $95 to $280 a night.

 Dog on a leash beside a tree-lined Upper Arlington sidewalk Comparisons & rankings Pet-friendly hotels near Upper Arlington

Pet fees around Upper Arlington run from $0 to $150 per stay depending on which of the six hotel clusters you pick — here is what each one charges, and the four parks worth the drive once you have checked in.

 Family walking past a suburban hotel entrance with a playground beyond Comparisons & rankings Family-friendly hotels near Upper Arlington, ranked

A family of four can sleep near Upper Arlington for $110 a night in Hilliard or $260 in Dublin — here are six clusters ranked on the four things that actually matter with kids, plus what to do with them once you are here.